Investing in Gold and Silver

What to Know About Investing in Gold and Silver

Time To Read 3 MIN READ

Precious metals have always had a unique allure, and history shows they have swung into and out of favor with investors many times. Their price surges in times of political upheaval or economic downturn, then drops when things look rosy. 

So should you take the golden plunge? Here are some tips about investing in precious metals.


Precious Metals as Insurance

"See this paper money? In 100 years, it'll be long gone." If you watch late-night TV, you may have seen the commercials urging you to buy gold today against a time when dollars and other paper currency will become worthless. 

Owning precious metals is considered by some to be an insurance policy, in case everything else you rely on fails. Some buyers liken buying silver and gold to buying homeowner's insurance ­– good to have in case the house burns down.


Gold as Inflation Hedge

Gold, and to a lesser extent, silver are also viewed as hedges against inflation and deflation. Some financial experts believe that gold belongs in everyone's portfolio to some extent. 

One such is Andrew Carrillo, a financial planner with Barnett Capital Advisors in Miami. Carrillo is quoted in AARP's article, "Should You Buy Gold?" as saying that he keeps fully 50 percent of his own investment assets in gold. He tells his retiree clients to hold at least 5 to 15 percent of their portfolio in gold.

"Their biggest risk is not running out of money," he says. "The biggest risk is their money running out of purchasing power."


Precious Metals Do Not Produce Income

Others argue against holding gold and silver in your portfolio, however, primarily because precious metals do not produce income. Many investors, especially those approaching retirement, seek investments that generate income. They believe they are better off with high-quality bonds, dividend-paying stocks or real estate investment trusts that pay out most of their earnings in dividends. Stocks usually appreciate over time and more than keep up with inflation. 

Even super-investor Warren Buffett argues against keeping precious metals in your portfolio. He noted in a letter to his shareholders that all the gold in the world would form a cube 68 feet in diameter and be valued at about the same price as all the farmland in America. But in 100 years, the 68-foot cube would still be just a cube, incapable of creating anything, while the farmlands would have yielded enormous amounts of edible crops.


Taxes and Price Drops

Taxes are another downside of owning precious metals. Gold is considered a collectible, so sale profits are taxed at 28 percent. Stock sale profits are taxed at a top rate of 15 percent. 

And the hard truth is that gold prices can fall staggeringly fast. In 2013, for example, gold lost about 28 percent of its value — and it fell even further in 2014. Silver is cheaper than gold, but historically even more volatile.


Bullion or Rare Coins

If you are still sold on gold and silver as a way to protect your assets from inflation and financial upset, what should you buy? 

According to Stefan Gleason, president of Money Metals Exchange in Eagle, Idaho, you'll want to go for the bullion coins and bars. "You want to avoid gold collectibles or rare coin products. Instead, buy bullion valued on its melt weight," Gleason advises. He says that numismatics — collectible precious metal pieces — are for speculators and hobbyists.